There is a reasonable objection to how inflation gets discussed. The measure policymakers pay most attention to excludes food and energy - which is to say, it excludes two of the things every household spends money on and notices most.
It sounds like a convenient way to report a lower number. The reasoning is better than that, but the criticism is not without merit either. This tutorial explains both sides.
The two measures
Headline inflation covers the whole basket, including food and energy. In the year to July 2026 it was 3.4%.
Core inflation excludes food and energy. Over the same period it was 2.5%.
That gap of nearly a percentage point is not a rounding difference. It is a substantial divergence, and understanding what causes it explains much of the current policy argument.
Why anyone excludes anything
The purpose of core is not to make inflation look tame. It is to separate two different things that the headline figure mixes together.
Some price changes reflect broad pressure across the economy - too much demand, rising wages, businesses able to charge more. That kind of inflation is persistent and responds to interest rates.
Other price changes reflect specific shocks to individual markets - a poor harvest, a pipeline outage, a conflict affecting shipping. That kind is temporary and does not respond to interest rates at all.
Core is an attempt to measure the first kind by removing the categories most prone to the second.
Why food and energy specifically
These two categories are unusually volatile and unusually driven by factors outside the domestic economy.
Energy prices depend on global supply, geopolitics, weather and production decisions made by other countries. Food prices depend on harvests, disease, weather and energy costs.
Both can swing violently in a single month and reverse just as quickly. Including them makes the monthly figure noisy in ways that obscure the underlying trend.
The interest rate argument
Here is the core of the reasoning, and it is genuinely persuasive.
Interest rates work by making borrowing more expensive, which reduces spending, which reduces the pressure on prices.
Now consider oil rising toward $91 a barrel because of renewed US-Iran tension and worries about the Strait of Hormuz. Would raising US interest rates increase the flow of oil through that shipping lane? Obviously not.
Raising rates in response would slow the domestic economy without addressing the cause. You would get the pain without the benefit.
This is why central banks say they look through supply shocks. It is not indifference to household costs. It is recognition that the tool does not fit the problem.
The counter-argument
Now the other side, which deserves a fair hearing.
People eat and drive. A household experiences headline inflation, not core. Being told the underlying trend is fine while your fuel bill climbs is legitimately frustrating.
Energy feeds into everything eventually. Transport, manufacturing, food distribution, plastics and fertiliser all depend on it. A sustained oil increase shows up in core prices months later, so excluding energy today does not exclude its effects tomorrow.
Expectations do not distinguish. If people see prices rising, they ask for higher wages regardless of which statistical category the increases fell into. A supply shock can therefore become embedded inflation through the expectations channel.
This last point is the strongest, and it is precisely what worries the Federal Reserve after more than five years above target.
Why the gap matters right now
The current gap between 3.4% headline and 2.5% core is largely an energy story, and it puts the committee in an awkward position.
By the textbook, they should look through the oil spike and focus on core, which is not far from the 2% target.
In practice, the public and markets see the headline number. After five years of overshooting, tolerance for explanations about which components do not count has worn thin. Fed chair Kevin Warsh's firm commitment at Jackson Hole to bringing inflation down was aimed at that credibility problem as much as at the data.
What to watch in the next report
The August figures are published on 11 September 2026. The relationship between the two measures will be informative.
If headline rises while core stays contained, the oil effect is doing what oil effects do - inflating the headline temporarily without spreading.
If core also rises, the energy shock is passing through into the wider economy, and the argument for looking through it collapses.
That distinction probably matters more for the Fed's decision than the headline figure itself.
Other measures that exist
Core is not the only attempt to filter out noise, and a few alternatives appear in commentary.
- Trimmed mean. Removes the most extreme price movements in both directions each month, whatever categories they happen to fall in.
- Median inflation. Takes the middle price change across all categories, ignoring extremes entirely.
- Sticky price inflation. Focuses on categories whose prices change infrequently, on the theory that these reflect genuine expectations.
- Supercore. Services excluding housing - the wage-driven part that policymakers watch most closely.
Each answers the same question differently: what is the underlying trend, stripped of temporary noise?
The supercore measure
This one deserves particular attention because it has become central to the current debate.
Services excluding housing captures things like insurance, medical care, repairs, haircuts and dining out. These are overwhelmingly the cost of people's time.
Because they are driven by wages, they are the stickiest part of inflation and the least responsive to interest rates in the short run. If this component is still running hot, the hawkish case is strong regardless of what energy is doing.
Which one is right?
The honest answer is that they measure different things and both are needed.
Core is better for understanding the trend and setting policy. Headline is better for understanding household experience and for anticipating how expectations will move.
A policymaker who watched only core would miss the credibility risk. One who reacted only to headline would tighten policy in response to shipping disruptions, which is worse than useless.
What it means for your money
For practical purposes, headline is the number that matters to you.
Your cost of living rises with the whole basket, not the filtered version. When judging whether a pay rise keeps you level, or whether your savings are keeping up, headline is the right comparison.
Core matters to you indirectly, because it drives interest rate decisions, which drive your mortgage, your savings rate and the value of your investments.
For traders
The market reaction to an inflation release is driven mainly by core, because core drives policy.
A hot headline with soft core frequently produces a muted or even contrary reaction, which confuses anyone watching only the top-line figure. Knowing which number the market is actually trading is the difference between understanding the move and being baffled by it.
Our walkthrough on reading the CPI report line by line covers the order to read the figures in.
The summary
Core inflation excludes food and energy not to flatter the number but to separate persistent pressure from temporary shocks, because interest rates can address the first and not the second.
The criticism that this ignores real household experience is fair, and the risk that a long enough supply shock becomes embedded through expectations is genuine.
In September 2026, with headline at 3.4%, core at 2.5% and oil near $91, that tension is not academic. It is the argument the Federal Reserve is currently having with itself.
When looking through a shock goes wrong
The strategy of ignoring supply shocks has a well-known failure mode, and it is worth understanding because it is exactly what the hawks fear.
Looking through a shock is correct when the shock is genuinely temporary. Prices rise, then stabilise, and the effect drops out of the annual figures a year later without any policy response needed.
It goes wrong when shocks keep arriving. A series of temporary disruptions, each individually justifiable to ignore, produces a sustained period of elevated prices. At that point the public stops distinguishing between temporary and persistent, because their experience is simply that things keep getting dearer.
Once that happens, wage demands adjust upward, businesses build higher increases into their planning, and the supply shock has been converted into ordinary inflation through the expectations channel.
This is why a central bank that has already missed its target for five years has much less freedom to look through the next shock than one with a clean record. Credibility is the resource being spent, and it has already been drawn down substantially.
Watching the gap over time
A practical habit: rather than looking at either measure alone, track the gap between them over several months.
A widening gap with headline above core means energy or food is pushing the total up while underlying pressure is contained. Uncomfortable but manageable.
A narrowing gap with core rising toward headline means the shock is passing through into the wider economy. This is the genuinely concerning pattern, because it indicates the supply problem has become a demand problem.
A gap that reverses, with core above headline, usually means energy prices are falling while services inflation persists. That was the pattern for much of the recent period, and it is why services became the focus.
Watching the relationship rather than either number individually gives you a far better sense of direction than any single monthly reading.
This article is general information, not financial advice. Do your own research or speak to a licensed professional before making money decisions.
General information, not advice. This article is published to everyone who reads it and takes no account of your circumstances, so it is not a personal recommendation. Trader Suite is not authorised or regulated by the FCA. Trading and investing involve a substantial risk of loss, and you should seek independent advice before acting. Our articles are researched and drafted with AI assistance and reviewed before publishing. Full risk disclosure.
TraderSuite Team
TraderSuite builds indicators and automated strategies for NinjaTrader 8. Our articles are written by the team, researched and drafted with AI assistance, and reviewed before publishing.






